Written by Rishabh Johri
Illustrated by Sneh Boro
Many of us have heard of circadian rhythms, and nearly all of us have suffered from the unravelling of our sleep schedules by yet another midterm season. Our health and mental processes depend on these sleep-wake cycles, determined by 24-hour oscillations of light and darkness. If we zoom in on the molecular level, circadian rhythms exert their control through tiny molecular clocks found in nearly every cell in our body. Our levels of alertness are maintained by an intricate balance of specialized “clock” proteins whose levels rise and fall in response to light and darkness. Like an orchestra, our circadian clock machinery is conducted by a master regulator that synchronizes the activity of these clock proteins and maintains the timing of various bodily processes¹.
Research on our biological clock has found that circadian rhythms tightly regulate everything from sleep to metabolism. However, much less is known about the link between circadian rhythms and the immune system. Recently, an exciting new field has emerged in immunology that looks at how our immune system functions according to the sleep-wake cycle. We are now learning that key processes in the development of an immune response like immune cell migration, activation, and antiviral responses are under the influence of our internal clocks². These findings have led to further studies investigating the influence of circadian rhythms on the efficacy of certain drugs, including blood pressure medications, cancer treatments, and vaccinations³. In theory, synchronizing the delivery of these treatments to optimize the activity of our body’s infection-fighting and inflammation-causing cells can improve clinical outcomes, with several studies showing promising results.
A recent study from the Washington School of Medicine has suggested that the COVID-19 mRNA vaccine may be better at preventing infection if doses are administered around midday⁴. When responding to viral infections or cancer, a group of immune cells known as CD8+ T cells become activated and generate a robust immune response that attacks and destroys infected or cancerous cells. Several studies have shown that CD8+ T cells function quite differently depending on the time of day. While these cells were found to be highly active at noon, they generated much weaker antiviral responses in the mornings and evenings, entering an almost sleep-like state³. “Chronovaccination” is an emerging concept in immunology which suggests that circadian rhythms can be harnessed to optimize vaccine responses based on the time of day. This is particularly important for higher-risk individuals whose immunocompromised state can prevent a robust vaccine response⁵. (insert illustration of a CD8+ T cell in a sleep-like state vs active state)
So, what does the fact that vaccinations are more effective at midday mean for night owls or those who work night shifts? Research shows that we might not need to panic if our circadian clock doesn’t follow a typical pattern. A study published this year in The Lancet’s eClinicalMedicine investigates the idea that everyone has a personalized internal clock, or “chronotype”, which can be harnessed so that even those with irregular sleep schedules can benefit from circadian timing of treatment delivery⁶. A chronotype refers to a person’s natural inclination towards certain sleep and wake times, determined by complex interactions between our genetically encoded “clock proteins”, and environmental factors like whether we are early birds or night owls⁶. In the study, chronotypes were used to optimize the time of delivery of hypertension drugs for each patient’s sleep schedule, which reduced the risk of a heart attack. The importance of timing in drug delivery is not a new concept — doctors and scientists have known that the time of day matters for the delivery of several drugs, with an estimated 50% of prescription medications hitting targets in the body that have circadian patterns⁷. However, recognizing that everyone operates on a unique schedule brings a new layer of personalization to medical treatment. So whether you are getting your annual flu shot, insulin injection, or life-saving chemotherapy, it’s important to know that timing can make a significant difference, and understanding your chronotype could help ensure that your immune system is ready when it matters most.
Sources:
- Cox, K.H. & Takahashi, J.S. Circadian clock genes and the transcriptional architecture of the clock mechanism. J. Mol. Endocrinol. 63, R93-r102 (2019).
- Holtkamp, S.J. et al. Circadian clocks guide dendritic cells into skin lymphatics. Nat. Immunol. 22, 1375-1381 (2021).
- Cermakian, N. et al. Circadian rhythms in adaptive immunity and vaccination. Semin. Immunopathol. 44, 193-207 (2022).
- Hazan, G. et al. Biological rhythms in COVID-19 vaccine effectiveness in an observational cohort study of 1.5 million patients. J Clin Invest. 11 (2023).
- Otasowie C.O. et al. Chronovaccination: Harnessing circadian rhythms to optimize immunisation strategies. Front Immunol. 13 (2022).
- Pigazzani, F. et al. Effect of timed dosing of usual antihypertensives according to patient chronotype on cardiovascular outcomes: the Chronotype sub-study cohort of the Treatment in Morning versus Evening (TIME) study. eClinicalMedicine, 72 (2024).
- Vlachou D. et al. TimeTeller: A tool to probe the circadian clock as a multigene dynamical system. PLoS Comput Biol. 2 (2024).